Benefits of Becoming a 1099 Employee vs. a W2 Employee

Introduction

Choosing between being a 1099 independent contractor or a W2 employee is an important decision that can significantly impact your work life and financial situation. Both statuses offer distinct advantages and come with specific legal and financial considerations. This document outlines these differences and provides specific pay information for both statuses within our organization.

W2 Employee

Benefits

  1. Consistent Pay Schedule: W2 employees receive regular paychecks, providing financial stability regardless of when the company receives payments from clients or insurance carriers.

  2. Tax Withholding: Taxes are automatically withheld from your paycheck, including federal, state, Social Security, and Medicare taxes, simplifying your tax obligations.

  3. Employment Benefits: W2 employees may be eligible for additional benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, and other perks provided by the employer.

  4. Job Security: As a W2 employee, you are covered by legal protections such as unemployment insurance and worker’s compensation.

  5. Simplified Tax Filing: The employer handles most of the tax paperwork, making it easier for you to file your annual taxes.

Pay Structure

  • Evaluation: $90 per session

  • 45-Minute Session: $55 per session

  • 60-Minute Session: $63 per session

  • Minimum Requirement: 10 sessions per week

Legalities

  • Employee Status: As a W2 employee, you are legally considered an employee of the company, meaning the company controls the work you do and how you do it.

  • Tax Obligations: The employer withholds income taxes, Social Security, and Medicare from your wages, and contributes the employer's share of employment taxes.

Explanation of Pay Rates

W2 employees are paid a lesser reimbursement rate because the employer covers a significant portion of the employment taxes and provides additional benefits that are not typically offered to independent contractors. This includes health insurance, retirement plans, and other perks which contribute to the overall compensation package.

1099 Independent Contractor

Benefits

  1. Higher Pay Per Session: 1099 contractors generally receive higher pay per session to compensate for the lack of employment benefits and tax withholding.

  2. Flexibility: You have more control over your work schedule and the methods you use to complete your tasks.

  3. Tax Deductions: As a 1099 contractor, you can deduct business expenses from your taxable income, including home office expenses, mileage, and other work-related costs.

  4. Autonomy: Operating as a self-employed individual gives you greater autonomy in your professional life.

Pay Structure

  • Evaluation: $100 per session

  • 45-Minute Session: $60 per session

  • 60-Minute Session: $70 per session

  • Minimum Requirement: 10 sessions per week

Legalities

  • Contractor Status: As a 1099 contractor, you are not an employee of the company. Instead, you provide services under a contractual agreement.

  • Tax Obligations: You are responsible for paying your own taxes, including self-employment tax, which covers Social Security and Medicare. Estimated tax payments must be made throughout the year.

  • Payment Schedule: 1099 contractors are paid once the payment from the insurance carrier is received, which can vary in timing.

Summary

Deciding between a 1099 independent contractor status and a W2 employee status depends on your individual preferences and financial goals.

  • W2 Employees benefit from job security, consistent pay, simplified tax filing, and access to employment benefits, albeit with a lower pay per session.

  • 1099 Independent Contractors enjoy higher pay per session, greater flexibility, potential tax deductions, and more professional autonomy, but with the responsibility of managing their own taxes and without the traditional employee benefits.

Consider these differences carefully to determine which status aligns best with your professional and personal goals. If you have any questions or need further clarification, please feel free to reach out.


Previous
Previous

From Fear to Freedom: Liberating BIPOC Mental Health Therapists in a White-Dominated Field